10th Annual Advanced Forum on

Securities Litigation & Enforcement

Preparing for the New Regulatory Enforcement Focus and Managing the Enforcement-Litigation Nexus

Wednesday, October 26 to Thursday, October 27, 2011
Metropolitan Hotel, Toronto, Ontario

Day 1: Wednesday, Oct 26, 2011

8:15
Registration Opens and Coffee Served
8:45
Opening Remarks from the Co-Chairs
  • Sébastien C. Caron
    Partner
    Heenan Blaikie LLP
  • John A. Fabello
    Partner
    Torys LLP
9:00
Examining New Securities Commission Enforcement Strategies and Initiatives
Moderator:
  • Mary G. Condon
    Vice-Chair of the OSC and Professor
    Osgoode Hall Law School‚ York University
Panelists:
  • Kathryn Daniels
    Deputy Director‚ Enforcement Branch
    Ontario Securities Commission
  • Lang Evans
    Director‚ Enforcement Division
    British Columbia Securities Commission
  • Jean-Francois Fortin
    Director‚ Inspections‚ Enforcement and Legal Affairs Division
    Autorité des Marchés Financiers
  • Don Young
    Chief Litigation Counsel
    Alberta Securities Commission
  • Practical implications of the changing strategic landscape for securities enforcement across Canada: Revealing new and recent enforcement priorities and initiatives:
    • Creative new enforcement initiatives being considered by the Ontario Securities Commission: The implications of no-admission settlements and other key initiatives
    • Understanding the recent separation of enforcement and criminal prosecutions at the British Columbia Securities Commission: Expanding the role of the commission into criminal prosecution – will other commissions follow suit?
    • To what extent have Canadian securities commissions been influenced by the U.S. Dodd-Frank Act and other U.S. initiatives?
    • Assessing international securities regulatory priorities and coordinated activity, and considering the impact of international regulatory coordination upon respondents
  • Realigning the regulated community’s relationship with the commissions: Analysing the shifting role and scope of securities beyond administrative and public interest proceedings into criminal prosecution
  • Uncovering key investigation and enforcement trends and commission targets:
    • What types of regulated community behavior are securities commissions seeing across the country?
    • On which activities are they focusing their eff orts?
    • Examining enforcement activity in traditional “core” enforcement areas vs. new areas of violations and market misconduct: How are the securities commissions dealing with exotic products and new trading strategies?
    • Determining areas of coordinated enforcement activity and priorities among the major commissions across Canada
    • Understanding how regulatory penalties are being set and proposed by Staff : Are uniformity and certainty factors considered by Staff ?
  • Update on the latest securities commission cases and decisions
10:30
Networking Refreshment Break
10:45
Securities Regulation in Flux: Impact on Securities Litigation Practice of Canadian Court Decisions on the National Securities Regulator, Multiple Exchanges and the TSX/LSE Merger
Moderator:
  • Linda Fuerst
    Partner
    Lenczner Slaght Royce Smith Griffin LLP

Impact of the Supreme Court of Canada and other Decisions on Securities Enforcement and Litigation across Canada

  • John B. Laskin
    Partner
    Torys LLP
  • Update on the constitutional challenge before the Alberta Court of Appeal, the Quebec Court of Appeal, and the Supreme Court of Canada
  • Which issues have been left open by the courts?
  • How does the proposed Canadian Securities Act deal with investigations and enforcement powers?
  • Determining how the proposed new regime may be run if a national regulator is deemed constitutional by the Supreme Court of Canada

Must-Have Updates on Multiple Markets

  • Mr. Sylvain Perreault
    Chief Compliance Officer
    Desjardins Group
  • The proposed acquisition of TMX by Maple Group and the situation with Alpha
  • Assessing the customer’s views on using the various trading systems and electronic platforms:
    • Pros and cons of the various trading systems and using multiple exchanges
12:15
Networking Luncheon for Delegates and Speakers
1:30
Regulatory Staff Insights into Minimizing the Impact of Regulatory Investigations and Enforcement Action
Moderator and Speaker:
  • Alistair Crawley
    Partner
    Crawley Meredith Brush LLP
Panelists:
  • Sean Horgan
    Manager‚ Enforcement
    Ontario Securities Commission
  • Michael Watson, Q.C.
    Special Advisor‚ Capital Markets‚Enforcement‚ Integrated Market‚Enforcement Program
    Royal Canadian Mounted Police
  • Understanding the underlying motives of the investigator:
    • What is the regulator trying to achieve by the investigation in a strategic context?
    • Means and deterrence: How securities regulators are putting a damper on rogue activity and improving enforcement activities
    • What types of offences are the regulators targeting and why?
  • At what point does a regulator determine that enforcement proceedings are appropriate?
  • Clarifying the disconnect on “credit for cooperation” between securities regulators and defence counsel
  • Determining how the regulatory and criminal processes are working together to achieve better enforcement results:
    • Examining the relationship between the regulatory side and the criminal arm: How are cases passed from the securities regulator to the criminal side?
    • Examining the track record on initiating and concluding criminal prosecutions
  • Defence counsel’s top tips for responding to the manner in which investigators exercise their powers
  • Managing an investigation to minimize operational disruption, reduce risk and keep costs down:
    • What are the regulators looking for? What information do they need and when?
    • Identifying the kind of evidence that can be collected by the regulator and at what stage of the investigation
    • Determining actions that can be taken to resolve problems at the heart of an investigation, avoid further proceedings or litigation and get to a settlement
    • Is there a limitation
2:45
Networking Refreshment Break
3:00
BREAK-OUT STREAMS
Please select either Stream A or Stream B
3:00 STREAM A: Key Developments in Canadian Securities Class Action Litigation
Panelists:
  • Jeffrey W. Galway
    Partner
    Blake Cassels & Graydon LLP
  • Michael Robb
    Partner
    Siskinds LLP
  • Determining the latest trends and certification rates in securities class actions litigation across the country
    • Are courts relaxing certification requirements? Which jurisdictions are less likely to certify actions?
  • Examining key recent cases in the past year: IMAX, Arctic Glacier, Timminco, and Gammon Gold
  • Uncovering new trends in class actions against MFDA members: Special considerations
  • Implications for the leave test of recent decisions in IMAX and Arctic Glacier:
    • Standard of leave, standard of proof, and key defences
    • Strategic considerations, limitation periods, and how the defences apply to individual issues
  • At what point is the limitation period applicable to a Part XXIII.1 claim suspended?
  • Propriety of a global class in secondary market liability class actions: Under what circumstances is a global class appropriate?
  • Examining the extent to which precertification discovery and access to documentation is allowed
  • Is there still a legitimate role for common law misrepresentation claims under securities legislation? Impact of the decision in Gammon Gold
  • Quantifying and valuing harm to investors in securities class action litigation: What are the different approaches that can be taken with regard to valuations in the absence of a baseline for Canada?
3:00 STREAM B: Managing Regulatory Investigations and Proceedings in the Criminal and Quasi-Criminal Realm: What Staff, Criminal and Administrative Lawyers Need to Know
Moderator:
  • Frank Addario
    Partner
    Sack Goldblatt Mitchell LLP
Panelists:
  • John Corelli
    Deputy Director‚ Crown Law Office - Criminal‚ Criminal Law Division
    Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General
  • Karen Manarin
    Deputy Director‚ Enforcement Branch
    Ontario Securities Commission
  • David W. Bellamy
    Superintendent Officer In Charge (OIC)
    Royal Canadian Mounted Police Toronto Integrated Market Enforcement Team (IMET)
  • Uncovering and analysing the results of the RCMP’s capital markets threat assessment: Directions in law enforcement in Canada and internationally
  • Managing the Crown’s onerous Stinchcombe disclosure standards in administrative proceedings
    • How are the disclosure requirements evolving?
    • Coordinating documentary production with other securities regulators across Canada and with the U.S. SEC: Key considerations and strategies to maximize disclosure effectiveness
  • Understanding the link between enforcement action and criminal proceedings
  • Working with Crown counsel and investigating to the criminal standard:
    • Crown counsel’s key considerations in going through the issues
    • Timing considerations
    • Determining how the rules of evidence change when an action is taken to court as opposed to dealing with it in an administrative context
    • What evidence can be admitted in each case? How do the consequences vary?
    • Applying the Criminal Code to securities regulation across Canada
  • Top tips and strategies for defending a criminal securities case:
    • Protecting clients from information-sharing requirements between regulatory and other bodies; ensuring that the information will not be used to incriminate your client
4:30
Current Trends in Regulatory and Civil Litigation Involving Brokers, Traders, Investment Bankers and Analysts
  • Wendy Berman
    Partner
    Heenan Blaikie LLP
  • Laura Paglia
    Partner
    Torys LLP
  • Who is being targeted in securities-related civil litigation and regulatory action?
  • Current state of litigation and regulatory action impacting brokers, traders, investment bankers and analysts:
    • What types of cases are impacting broker-dealers and investment advisers the most?
    • Which financial industries are most under scrutiny?
    • Is enforcement becoming tougher and more targeted?
    • Review of leading recent broker-dealer cases
  • Interplay between regulatory investigations and civil litigation: Determining the impacts of an investigation on the commencement of civil proceedings
5:30
Co-Chairs’ Remarks and Forum Adjourns

Cocktail Reception to follow

Sponsored by:

www.duffandphelps.ca

Day 2: Thursday, Oct 27, 2011

8:15
Coffee Served
8:45
Opening Remarks from the Co-Chairs
9:00
The Latest Enforcement Developments at IIROC and the MFDA
Moderator:
  • John A. Fabello
    Partner
    Torys LLP
Panelists:
  • Hugh Corbett
    Director of Litigation
    Mutual Fund Dealers Association of Canada
  • Elsa Renzella
    Director, Litigation
    Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada
  • Interpreting developments in enforcement priorities and activity at IIROC and the MFDA:
    • What the latest enforcement priorities and actions reveal about investment dealer/advisor behavior
    • Key enforcement priorities and market-related issues including high frequency trading and DART pool trading
    • How SROs are treating high-risk new products and the latest product issues
  • Practical implications of IIROC’s new consolidated enforcement rules on the regulated community:
    • Principal differences from the previous regime
    • Advising on changing relationship issues and minimizing the risk of enforcement action
  • Examining the MFDA’s new penalty guidelines
  • Understanding IIROC and MFDA collaboration, cooperation and coordination with other securities regulatory entities:
    • How is information shared between and used by the regulatory bodies in both Canada and the U.S.? What the regulated community and their advisors need to know
  • SRO perspectives on accountability and liability of an employer for failing to supervise salespeople
10:15
Networking Refreshment Break
10:30
Uncovering Current Developments in Fraud Enforcement and Litigation: Ponzi Schemes, Boiler Room Activities, Social Networking Schemes and Others
Moderator:
  • Kelley McKinnon
    Partner
    Gowling LaFleur Henderson LLP
Panelists:
  • Michael Van Klaveren
    Deputy Director‚ Proceeds and Securities‚Commercial Crime‚ Proceeds and Securities Section‚ British Columbia
    Ministry of Attorney General
  • Don Young
    Chief Litigation Counsel
    Alberta Securities Commission
  • James Coates
    Lead Investigator, Criminal Investigations
    British Columbia Securities Commission
  • Cameron Watson
    Senior Litigation Counsel, Enforcement Branch
    Ontario Securities Commission
  • Examining the latest trends and enforcement action relating to Ponzi schemes, boiler room activities, social networking schemes and other fraudulent activity
  • Identifying the level of burden of proof depending on the nature of the allegations
  • Assessing recent growing trends and focused eff orts on fraudulent financial schemes against elders and vulnerable adult populations fraud
  • Determining changes in remedies for fraud actions
  • Following the life of a fraud fi le after it leaves the hearing room
  • How regulatory authorities are examining trading patterns in relation to public disclosure and conducting investigations into perceived insider trading
    • Under what circumstances are insider trading cases being dealt with in criminal proceedings under the Criminal Code?
    • Gathering evidence in insider trading cases for successful prosecutions: What kind of evidence do you need? What tools are available to securities regulators?
12:00
Networking Luncheon for Delegates and Speakers
1:15
Managing Cross-Venue and Cross-Jurisdictional Regulatory and Civil Litigation and Enforcement Proceedings
  • Douglas W. Henkin
    Partner
    Milbank (New York)
  • Ian R. Smith
    Partner
    Fenton Smith Barristers
  • Brendan Van Niejenhuis
    Partner
    Partner, Stockwoods LLP
  • Managing issues having multiple implications and consequences: Regulatory implications, civil litigation implications, corporate transactional considerations
  • Managing time and costs
  • Handling current litigation with concurrent regulatory matters:
    • Key defence considerations and strategies
    • Keeping the issues related to the civil action in mind during the course of an investigation or regulatory proceeding
  • Top tips to take a holistic approach to the situation
  • Implications of the U.S. Supreme Court decisions on securities claims being brought in Canada by foreign investors and the AIG jurisdiction issue
  • Managing issues in cross-border securities actions and evaluating the emerging role of U.S. firms:
    • Litigation strategies for cross-border cases: Managing jurisdictional interplay and moving forward on a coordinated basis
    • Are Canadian companies with U.S. operations seeing more class action claims moving north?
  • Determining linkages between regulatory investigations and enforcement proceedings and class action litigation: Key issues arising out of Fischer v. IG Investment Management Inc.
  • Examining securities regulatory collaboration and coordination within Canada and in cross-border and international securities class actions: How regulators are working together to maximize opportunities to return money to the investors
2:30
Networking and Refreshment Break
2:45
In-House Perspectives on Managing Risk, Resources, Reputation and Process in Regulatory Enforcement Proceedings and Litigation
Moderator:
  • Sébastien C. Caron
    Partner
    Heenan Blaikie LLP
Panelists:
  • Julie Clarke
    Assistant Vice President and Chief Counsel
    Manulife Securities Incorporated
  • Francois Lavallée
    Senior Vice-President‚ Legal Affairs
    Financial Markets and Wealth Management
  • Martin MacLachlan
    Senior Vice-President‚ Legal Affairs
    Canaccord Genuity
  • Michael Petrocco
    Associate General Counsel & Managing‚Director‚ BMO Financial Group - BMO
    Capital Markets
  • How do recent securities enforcement and litigation trends impact internal decision-making at the client level?
  • Principal in-house counsel risk management considerations and strategies for dealing with regulatory enforcement and litigation
  • Defining in-house counsel’s big-picture issues:
    • Managing internal resources and budgets for litigation
    • Understanding concerns around public communications issues
  • Advising the Board on new and growing exposures in Canada and cross-border
  • What do in-house counsel expect from outside counsel?
  • Uncovering employment issues arising from regulatory investigations: Reviewing the latest high-profile cases
  • Examining insurance coverage considerations in securities litigation and enforcement:
    • What new products are available? What to look out for, how to read a policy, advising clients
    • Gaining the insurer’s perspectives on insurance coverage for securities enforcement action and litigation
  • Impacts on success in regulatory enforcement proceedings of self-representation
  • Impact of an investigation, proceeding, or litigation on compliance monitoring: Top tips for fixing existing compliance systems and training staff
4:00
Assessing Current Trends in Transactional and Public Disclosure Litigation: Magna, Biovale, Baffinland, Lionsgate, Potash and Others
  • Mark Gelowitz
    Partner
    Osler Hoskin & Harcourt LLP
  • James C. Tory
    Partner
    Torys LLP
  • Examining litigation arising out of poison pills and takeovers:
    • Recent case law developments
    • Uncovering the extent to which courts are striking down poison pills
    • Forecasting directions for poison pill litigation in Canada
  • Determining the intersection between corporate remedies and securities litigation:
    • Considering choice of remedial actions to maximize shareholder and investor results: Using oppression actions, shareholder activism or litigation and proceedings
    • Proxy fight litigation: Which issues get litigated?
  • Impact of Biovale on the continuing disclosure regime
  • Is competition law the new foil for deal makers? TSX and Potash
  • Impact of the OSC’s decision in CI Financial Corp.
5:00
Co-Chairs’ Closing Remarks – Conference Concludes

Workshop: Friday, Oct 28, 2011

A:
9:30AM
POST-FORUM WORKSHOP
Effectively Managing Broker-Dealer Supervision and Litigation
Friday, October 28, 2011 | 9:30 a.m. – 12:30 p.m.
  • Rob Brush
    Partner
    Crawley Meredith Brush LLP
  • Shawn Graham
    Senior Counsel
    Royal Bank of Canada
  • Identifying the most common abuses and how can they be detected and stopped internally
  • Updates on the latest priorities and enforcement initiatives:
    • Assessing the role of and scope of institutional supervision of brokers on the retail end by both regulatory bodies and the courts
    • Minimizing risks and exposure to federal, provincial and SRO enforcement
  • What broker-dealers and investment advisers can do to prepare compliance programs for current enforcement priorities:
    • How do you share information with the regulators?
  • Coordinating with outside counsel to help prevent and manage regulatory attention
    • Strategies for preventing an investigation from turning into an enforcement action
    • Coping with regulatory document requests, investigations, and on-on-the record testimony
    • Managing multiple actions and claims
    • Strategies to advance or defend against broker claims when facing regulatory, criminal and investigative proceedings
  • Determining extent of liability of employers for individual brokers’ actions:
    • Strategies to minimize broker misconduct: Training and monitoring
  • Options available to the employer to risk assess and risk manage broker misconduct
  • Top tips to manage and monitor the broker-client relationship be managed to avoid disputes and litigation